What Black Mirror Can Tell Us About Modern Marketing

Black Mir­ror is The Twi­light Zone for the mod­ern age, minus the reas­sur­ing pres­ence of Rod Ser­ling. Its main writer, Charlie Brooker, has spent a life­time bur­ied in social media, pop cul­ture and the worst advert­ising tat our gen­er­a­tion has been able to spew out into the world, so it’s not that sur­pris­ing that the stor­ies Black Mir­ror tells are a twis­ted, dis­turb­ing but pain­fully accur­ate reflec­tion of mod­ern times.

And one of the things it has a lot to say about is the way mar­ket­ing works now. If you work in mar­ket­ing then you’d be right to feel insul­ted by Black Mir­ror – it’s abund­antly clear from the six epis­odes that have been made so far that Charlie Brooker doesn’t like you one bit. How­ever, he’s also got a lot of use­ful things to say that could actu­ally help you under­stand your industry.

It’s not a mir­ror, it’s a lens

The name of the show, Black Mir­ror, refers to screens. It doesn’t mat­ter what the screens are. It could refer to your TV, your laptop mon­itor, your iPad, your phone, the screens show­ing adverts that you pass on the tube or the screen by your hos­pital bed play­ing a looped greet­ing by the health sec­ret­ary. To be a human in West­ern civil­isa­tion in the 21st cen­tury is to spend your life look­ing at a vari­ety of dif­fer­ently sized glow­ing rect­angles, as Charlie Brooker him­self has poin­ted out.

But in Black Mir­ror the screens don’t just reflect ourselves back at us. Instead the tech­no­logy is the way we see the world. In White Bear the crowds of spec­tator zom­bies view everything through the screen on their phone, a sight that you know not to be sci­ence fic­tion if you’ve been to a live gig recently. In The Waldo Moment the main char­ac­ter is bet­ter known as the blue, CGI bear he plays than he is as a per­son. In Fif­teen Mil­lion Mer­its the protagonist’s bed­room walls are simply huge screens, and he leaves that room to go and ride an exer­cise bike in front of other screens dur­ing the day – he’s more likely to see his friends’ car­toon­ish Wii Mii style avatars than the real people. As someone who has intro­duced myself to people at parties only to dis­cover I speak to them daily on Twit­ter, I can identify with that.

What does that teach us?

Basic­ally, we now live in the Mat­rix. From a busi­ness per­spect­ive the vir­tual world is now every bit as real to people as the phys­ical world. The lines are get­ting blur­rier all the time, with video­games build­ing eco­nom­ies that can match some coun­tries, and products like Google Glass aim­ing to bring aug­men­ted real­ity into the main­stream (which you can be sure mar­ket­ing will take advant­age of). Right now what this means is that your online pres­ence is very much how people see your com­pany, which means if you ruin your social media cam­paign, it’s going to hurt.

Your life exper­i­ences are now a commodity

Two of the Black Mir­ror stor­ies deal with this dir­ectly. In The Entire His­tory of You, every­body is con­stantly record­ing everything they see and hear, with the abil­ity to refer back to it at will. Your employ­ers can ask to have a look through your record­ings as part of a job inter­view, and then after­wards you can replay the job inter­view over and over, lit­er­ally. Secur­ity guards at air­ports can check over your memory before let­ting you on the plane. If you’re hav­ing an argu­ment with your part­ner about some­thing you said last week, you can go back and review the footage.

It’s sci­ence fic­tion, but not quite as sci­ence fic­tional as it could be in a world where people reg­u­larly pho­to­graph their meals and upload them to the Inter­net, and employ­ers think it’s accept­able to ask to see your Face­book login inform­a­tion.

It goes a step fur­ther in Be Right Back, how­ever, where com­pan­ies are offer­ing to take all your social media inform­a­tion and use it to cre­ate a com­pu­ter­ised ghost of you, who talks exactly like you would while gently up-​selling your griev­ing loved ones from a text chat inter­face up to a fully real­istic robot rep­lica. Oh, and there’s already a real com­pany offer­ing the same ser­vice.

What does that teach us?

There’s a pop­u­lar say­ing about people who use social media. They aren’t the cus­tom­ers – they’re the product. Social media sites acquire vast num­bers of users, who will­ingly pour all their inform­a­tion into the site, then they sell that inform­a­tion or use it to dir­ect mar­ket­ing at their cus­tom­ers. And their reach is broad­en­ing – with sites like Foursquare and Facebook’s check-​in option, com­bined with smart phones, these sites have access not just to your likes, demo­graphic inform­a­tion, friend­ship net­work and rela­tion­ship status, they can also track your move­ments and routines. With Google Glass on the way, the reach of these sites is going to go even fur­ther, to the point where ser­vices like the one in The Entire His­tory of You aren’t entirely implausible.

Dis­sent is a mar­ket­ing tool

There’s a lot to be said for George Orwell, but you’ve got to admit the guy thought small. In 1984 the gigantic evil dysto­pian gov­ern­ment deals with rebel­lion by lock­ing it in a room and tor­tur­ing it until it doesn’t want to rebel any­more. In Charlie Brooker’s uni­verse this is seen as an awful lot of unne­ces­sary effort. In 15 Mil­lion Mer­its the prot­ag­on­ist is driven to des­pair by the soci­ety he lives in, and ends up burst­ing onto the stage of a Britain’s Got Tal­ent style show with a shard of broken glass pressed up against his neck. He then launches into a speech about all the ter­rible things that are wrong with the dysto­pia they’re stuck in. The judges respond by giv­ing him his own show.

In The Waldo Moment the main char­ac­ter doesn’t even want to rebel against the powers that be, he just wants to make lots of knob gags, with the people around him shov­ing him onto the polit­ical stage, where his CGI bear becomes an icon for the dis­en­fran­chised. Soon shad­owy Amer­ic­ans are talk­ing about what a great polit­ical product the bear could become, and by the end of the show an Orwellian dysto­pia has been cre­ated – with blue bear pic­tures everywhere.

In Brooker’s world you don’t crush dis­sent, you repack­age and sell it.

What does that teach us?

A huge part of the mes­sage the gen­eral mass of advert­ising gives us is “You’re spe­cial. You’re unique. Oth­ers might fol­low the crowd and do as they’re told, but you’re a free thinker, a rebel who doesn’t play by the rules. Buy hair gel.” We all want to think we’re Luke Sky­walker (okay, Han Solo) and nobody wants to be one of the anonym­ous storm troop­ers. This isn’t new. Hell, in 1984 Apple was using 1984 to sell com­puters. See also this example of an ad where eat­ing at McDonald’s for lunch is por­trayed as the first chapter of Das Kapital.

Even bet­ter, take this very art­icle, which takes some of the most bit­ing satire writ­ing in the last couple of years and meta­morph­os­ises it into a list of hints and tips on how to be a bet­ter mar­ket­ing man­ager. The world is becom­ing more and more like an epis­ode of Black Mir­ror every day. Which is some­thing David Cameron should worry about.

Attached Images:
  • License: Image author owned

Sam Wright is a freel­ance writer who always pre­ferred The Outer Limits.

Be Soci­able, Share!

One thought on “What Black Mirror Can Tell Us About Modern Marketing

  1. Its like you read my mind! You seem to know so much about this, like you wrote the book in it or some­thing. I think that you could do with a few pics to drive the mes­sage home a little bit, but other than that, this is mag­ni­fi­cent blog. A fant­astic read. I will cer­tainly be back. int­ress­ant artikel http://​j3nn​.net/​b​l​o​g​/​2​0​1​2​/​1​0​/​2​3​/​m​o​n​d​a​y​-​m​u​s​i​n​g​s​-​v​o​l​-5/

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

CommentLuv badge